Who do you pefer Beth or Shelley?.

[j.laur5]

Who do you think was the better Pippa replacement.

I liked Shelley but I preferred Beth as she came across are a more realistic mother!.

[Jezz]

I prefer Beth over Shelley but I do feel that Shelley was better suited with Rhys than Beth was.

Both were strong motherly figures but the way Shelley walked out on her family after many years makes me believe that Beth resembled more traits of the way Pippa was like as a foster mother in contrast to Shelley.

[Angelica]

I prefer Beth over Shelley but I do feel that Shelley was better suited with Rhys than Beth was.

Both were strong motherly figures but the way Shelley walked out on her family after many years makes me believe that Beth resembled more traits of the way Pippa was like as a foster mother in contrast to Shelley.

I would agree with this. I preferred Beth and thought she was actually the kind of character you would want to interact with in real life. However, I also agree that Shelley was more suited to Rhys.

[Slade]

Shelly because I enjoyed a more lot of the storylines surrounding her character and some of the other Sutherlands and her relationship with her daughters although I thought Beth was a much nicer and warmer person. I will say that one massive thing I really liked about Beth was her apparent pro KK stance and if it wasn't for her Rhys would have annulled their marriage for sure.