Harry became convinced that Sally wasn't really in love with Luke and kissed her in order to prove a point. A defiant Sally insisted she did love Luke but deep down she was having doubts. When Brett Egan, who had been a student teacher at the school, returned full time, he and Sally spent a lot of time together. Sally tried to set him up with Shauna but Shauna suggested he be careful because it was really Sally he was interested in. Fisher continually pushed them together at school and in extra curricular activities, leaving Sally feeling uncomfortable and doubting her feelings for Luke. She and Brett shared a kiss and Sally ended her relationship with Luke.
Another hangover from her failed wedding the previous year occurred when she struggled to enter the church as one of Leah's bridesmaids. However Colleen managed to talk around and she walked up the aisle behind Leah. Right after this wedding, Sally visited Canada. However, whilst she was there, she contracted pneumonia and ended up having to extend her stay by a fortnight. On her return she agreed to Gypsy continuing to stay at her house, despite the role Gypsy had played in the failure of her wedding the previous year. Sally soon uncovered that Gypsy was carrying Will's baby and tried to push the couple together, but kept her word, saying that she would not tell Will.
It was smooth sailing at first with their first couple of dates being a disaster. One was called off when Flynn got stuck at the drop-in centre with some deaf girl and then on another occasion Flynn was called to the city after a sighting of his sister Ashley. When they finally managed to go on a date, Sally dressed up expecting some glitzy dinner, however Flynn had planned an abseiling picnic and Sally ended up horrendously overdressed. Despite everything they had a good date and Sally grew more smitten.
Flynn soon recovered his drug addict sister Ashley from some squat in the city and Sally's relationship was forced to take a back seat for a period of time. Just as it appeared that Ashley was overcoming her habit, Terry, her old drug supplier arrived in the bay. She ran to the drop-in centre looking for help and in the scuffle that enused Sally was injured against a chest of drawers.
Upon her admission to hospital Sally was diagnosed as having an ovarian cancer, though thankfully it was removed without much problem. Unfortunately for Sally this meant that she would be unable to have children and believing that Flynn would no longer want a woman like her. However she was wrong and Flynn's constant hanging around outside her front door eventually convinced her otherwise.