Rachel or Tony

[jodlebirger]

Definately Tony!! I think that he probably should have left by now (because the writers seem to have forgotten about Tonys history on the show, he never talks about Lucas for example), but he is so much better than Rachel.

She is so overplayed with all her facial expressions, and she is moaning all the time. And I'm not only talking about right now with the PND stuff, but she has been complaining since she entered the show. And she always deal with things in the most self destructive ways. The drinking when her mother died, slapping Leah etc...

Tony was in the beginning great with his sons, especially Lucas. I loved the interaction between them. And I liked him with Beth. I think that Tony is drowning in Rachel, she steals the show all the time and not in a good way. I think it's sad to see that all he is doing is to satisfy Rachel.

[j.laur5]

Yeah I agree they have fans but I think both Tony and Rachel's time is up on the show.

[-g-l-a-m-o-r-ous-]

Dislike both but between the two it's Tony

[Barbara]

I like Rachel but I love Tony so I voted for him.

[Red Ranger 1]

Another one I found really difficult.Used to really love Rachel but I think things went a bit wrong when she and Kim split up, it felt like they were trying to make her annoying so he wouldn't look bad for walking out on her and she never really got back up to her old level.Nowadays, in both cases I tend to vary between really liking them and finding them annoying.But I really like Tony more and find him annoying less so he got the vote.

[devon]

Neither really...but if I had to chose, I'd go for Rachel over Tony baloney.

[mbi615]

I did use to like Rachel but now she's getting quite annoying. I voted for Tony coz I loved his relationships with Jack and Lucas and like most people have said, he is slightly less annoying.

[richleamington]

Tony might not be the most interesting character but he's a pretty sound guy and the show needs an older male figure along with Alf to give it balance. Rachel is just annoying a lot of the time, but ok some of the time.

[Georgia]

Had to vote for Tony, because I loved his interactions with Lucas and Jack.

Rachel used to be a really great character, but now she just seems to be dragging Tony down with her.

[halcyon06]

Love them both but I picked Rachel.